People's Choice Restaurant

Authentic Jamaican Comfort on Central Avenue

People's Choice Restaurant is a established destination in East Orange for those seeking genuine Caribbean cuisine. Located on a busy stretch of Central Avenue, this no-frills eatery has spent two decades serving up a vast menu of island classics. It is widely recognized by locals as a reliable spot for traditional dishes that stay true to authentic recipes.

The menu highlights the best of Jamaican soul food, featuring slow-cooked proteins like tender curry goat, savory oxtail, and brown stew chicken. For diners looking for a quick bite, their selection of patties—ranging from classic beef to spinach and cheese—alongside handmade roti skins, offers a perfect taste of the tropics on the go. Every platter is built with a focus on deep, incredible flavor and generous portion sizes.

While the atmosphere is casual and the service is straightforward, the restaurant remains a community fixture. Whether you are stopping in for a large bowl of hearty goat soup or picking up a platter of ackee and saltfish, People’s Choice provides an authentic culinary experience that "understands the assignment" when it comes to Caribbean comfort food.

Iconic Menu Highlights

Curry Goat Platter

A standout favorite known for its deep spice profile and generous portions of tender, fresh meat.

Oxtails

Slow-cooked and perfectly seasoned, these rich oxtails are a premium choice for a satisfying dinner.

Ackee and Saltfish

A large, authentic preparation of Jamaica's national dish, perfect for any time of day.

Fresh Beef Patties

Flaky, golden pastries filled with savory seasoned beef, served fresh throughout the day.

Goat, Beef, and Cowfoot Soup

Hearty, traditional soups available in large servings that are a local favorite for a warming meal.

Curried Chicken Roti

A flavorful and filling option featuring tender curried chicken wrapped in a soft, authentic roti skin.

Customer reviews

Long-time patrons and visitors alike frequently mention the incredible depth of flavor and the satisfying, large portions served at this local gem.

Food has been good here for about 20 years. They understand the assignment.

- A. Clinton

The curry goat platter was amazing! Fresh food and huge portions. Definitely coming back.

- Vishal Bhavsar

★★★★★

★★★★★

Map & Direction

Located at 63 Central Ave in East Orange, NJ. It is a convenient stop for authentic Caribbean takeout along one of the city's main thoroughfares.