Coney Island
A beloved, family-owned "hole-in-the-wall" eatery in East Orange specializing in all-day Halal breakfast platters, massive New York-style gyros, and fresh comfort food.
Phone
(973) 676-4214
Hours
Tuesday - Thursday 4:30 AM - 3:00 PM, Friday 4:30 AM - 1:00 PM, Saturday - Monday 4:30 AM - 3:00 PM
Address
357 Main St, East Orange, NJ 07018
Social Media
N/A
Legendary Halal Breakfast & Gyros on Main Street
Coney Island is a small, highly-rated hidden gem located on Main Street in East Orange, NJ. Run by two incredibly friendly brothers, this cozy establishment has built a massive local following for its fresh, flavorful Halal food and exceptional customer service. While the dining space is small and primarily designed for takeout, the massive portions and top-tier ingredients make it a must-visit destination for early risers and lunch crowds alike.
Serving food starting at 4:30 AM, Coney Island is famous for its all-day breakfast menu, which features perfectly spiced beef sausages, fluffy pancakes, and fresh fish platters served with creamy grits or home fries. For lunch, the kitchen pivots to massive, New York-style street food platters, offering what many locals claim is the best gyro on the East Coast. If you are looking for clean, fast, and finger-licking good comfort food in East Orange, this is the spot!
Iconic Menu Highlights
Whiting Fish and Grits Platter
A phenomenal, highly recommended all-day breakfast option featuring fresh whiting, perfectly spiced cheese eggs, and warm grits.
New York Style Gyros
Widely considered the best on the East Coast by locals, available in beef, chicken, or falafel.
Mixed Platter (3 Meats)
A massive, satisfying specialty platter loaded with your choice of chicken, lamb, and shrimp served over rice.
Beef Bacon, Egg & Cheese
A classic, 10/10 breakfast sandwich that is completely Halal, served on a fresh roll, bagel, or buttery croissant.
Italian Cheesesteak
A hearty lunch option made with real steak and packed with flavor.
Homemade Iced Tea
The perfect refreshing drink to pair with your meal, available in Uptown or Fruit Punch flavors.
Customer reviews
Reviewers constantly praise the incredible food quality, the generous portions, and the incredibly warm and friendly service provided by the owners.
The whiting fish and grits breakfast platter with the cheese eggs was phenomenal... they SPICED EVERYTHING PROPERLY. Also, the owners are a very nice...
- Esteban Carrion III
Friend service, two brothers, and great food! Best pancakes, gyros, and pretty much everything else that I've ever tasted. Great ingredients and flavors. Halal food has never tasted so good!
- James Werner
★★★★★
★★★★★
Map & Direction
Located at 357 Main St in East Orange, NJ. It's a small, bustling spot, so calling your order in ahead of time is highly recommended during busy weekend mornings!